FYI: This was posted just now, but pre-dated to allow the latest "Revisiting..." entry to remain at the top of the front page.

Best of luck -- you'll probably need it for this one!

YEM 12/9/95

Funky Bitch 12-30-96

Just a guess, although I seem to remember the crowd being louder than that when the sound cut out.

limb by limb 7/1/97

@jwp86 said:

Funky Bitch 12-30-96

beat me to my guess

Oh come on.

7/3/11 Reba

My guess would be Divided Sky. Perhaps the first one to incorporate the long pause...whenever that was....?

@Doctor_Smarty said:

7/3/11 Reba

it's def not a 3.0 IMO where crowd is more restrained

2/28/91 Golgi is my guess. (The PhishTracks version fades out before loss of power.)

Divided Sky 6/18/94

9/25/99 Limb by Limb

@Laidig said:

My guess would be Divided Sky. Perhaps the first one to incorporate the long pause...whenever that was....?

That's exactly what I thought. And I think it was UIC '94 as referenced by Trey in the infamous Charlie Rose interview during which he discussed, among other things, the break-up.

The crowd isn't restrained, it's tiny. I think the latest this could be is one of the smaller 94 shows. I can't believe I'm even pondering possibilities.

Here's the link to my review that has Trey's quotation:

http://phish.net/reviews/permalink.php?commentid=1357607855

ROFL I love this guy @bl002e your awesome.

Just to get a kick I'm gonna throw out 10/30/98 Driver> Freebird LOL

@andrewrose said:

The crowd isn't restrained, it's tiny. I think the latest this could be is one of the smaller 94 shows. I can't believe I'm even pondering possibilities.

Though I think my guess is wrong (even though tomorrow is the anniversary), I'm glad that I made an impulse guess so I don't have to put myself through the agony of actually thinking deeply about this, or, Icculus forbid, actually start going through crowd noise on PhishTracks or iTunes...

Ha, I came on late and I am listening and laughing to myself over here. My prediction is that the hint (if needed) will be "This is not from an acapella song".

My guess is 10/7/95 Spokane Harry Hood.

It sounds like an outdoor '98 to me. Gonna go with

7.21.98 AC/DC Bag

I've been screaming for a MJM from this show for a while but I never thought the MJM would be the crowd portion of the Bag.

12/4/94 Foam

4/14/94 Dog Faced Boy

Last week, from @bl002e:

"Guys, gals, don't be appalled if next week's selection ends up being a silent jam."

I guess we're not allowed to be appalled!

I have a hunch this is a Simple of some kind.

Pretty sure yunkfunk nailed it. Listen for the distinctive whoops around 6:10-6:20.

Assuming that's right, s/he* ID'd about 30 seconds worth of crowd noise in less than an hour. Not bad.

* Has a woman ever won Mystery Jam?

@HarborSeal said:

Pretty sure yunkfunk nailed it. Listen for the distinctive whoops around 6:10-6:20. Assuming that's right, s/he* ID'd about 30 seconds worth of crowd noise in less than an hour. Not bad. * Has a woman ever won Mystery Jam?

Gotta be honest. Not sure if I did or not. Pretty sure it's Foam that they go back into at the end of the snippet from hell...

Not a woman, though. Sorry to disappoint @HarborSeal...whether I win or not.

that does sound a bit like it, i was originally thinking an esther. tough one to peg.

Was thrown off by what almost sounded like a "Farmer in the Dell" tease, which had me focused on 4/4/94. And that shows was further intriguing because of the a capella start of the show, which is cut off in most recordings, but alas... Amazing work, @yunkfunk.

Almost sounds like secret language

i think it's a foam

12/04/1994 Foam!

SHIT

Good job @yunkfunk

well done well done!! bet bl002e thought he had us stumped

When I finally thought of a logical solution, it'd already been solved:

http://lmgtfy.com/?q=site%3Aphish.net+AND+%22silent+jam%22

@uctweezer said:

Here's the link to my review that has Trey's quotation:

http://phish.net/reviews/permalink.php?commentid=1357607855[/quote] />
Thanks ucpete, I always wondered how the pause came to be.

I declare shenanigans, get your brooms! That's no JAM, thats crowd noise. Damn you @bl002e!! Thirty years of music and stretching that hard?? N1.

@andrewrose said:

Oh come on.

I'm not even going to give this one a second listen. Lame.

12/4/94 was my first show... the night my life changed forever. I was hooked from the first song (Jim), and I distinctly remember this silent jam. I am so glad I got to see them in this (relatively) small venue before it was amphitheaters and arenas for years to come. Glad to see this sleeper of a gem of a show get some love!!

@phishncincy said:

I declare shenanigans, get your brooms! That's no JAM, thats crowd noise. Damn you @bl002e!! Thirty years of music and stretching that hard?? N1.

@dyn0mite said:

I'm not even going to give this one a second listen. Lame.

And yet, it took less than the length of your average Phish set for someone to solve it. Hmmm.

ay ay ay

My god, look at us? We're listening to crowd noise trying to guess the song/date.

I was kidding. I ended it with N1(nice one). I thought it was funny it was already solved before I got to even listen to it.

@phishncincy said:

I was kidding. I ended it with N1(nice one). I thought it was funny it was already solved before I got to even listen to it.

No worries at all -- I took it as good-natured rubbing at worst.